All Her Fault movie review & film summary (2025) | Roger Ebert

All Her Fault Movie Review & Film Summary (2025)

All Her Fault is a tension-filled thriller that grips like a sudden sinkhole and twists like a venomous snake pit. The story opens with a nightmare: Marissa (Sarah Snook) arrives at a playdate to pick up her son, Milo (Duke McCloud), only to find the host, Jenny (Dakota Fanning), unaware and unhelpful. From this unsettling start, the suspense only deepens.

Based on Andrea Mara's novel, the series immediately captures your attention as soon as Milo goes missing. The first episode sets a tone of rising anxiety, designed to provoke strong emotions. Every minor mistake, every suspicious glance, and the weight of blame are portrayed with vivid intensity, making viewers want to shout at the screen.

Characters and Suspicion

Each character's motives are shrouded in doubt: Marissa and her husband Peter (Jake Lacy), other mothers, nannies (Kartiah Vergara, Sophia Lillis), family members (Abby Elliott, Daniel Monks), and even a business partner (Jay Ellis). All carry shadows of potential guilt, assuring viewers that everyone has secrets.

Complex Storytelling

Flashbacks stretching back ten years reveal intertwined storylines, though these glimpses often confuse more than clarify. This ambiguity enhances the series' intrigue, offering a cat-and-mouse dynamic that keeps the audience guessing.

“All Her Fault” is an anxiety-inducing thriller with the sudden drops of a sinkhole and the venomous twists of a snake pit.
Every mistake, every glare of blame, and suspicion is rendered in vivid detail.
Author's Summary

“All Her Fault” masterfully blends suspense and psychological complexity, pulling viewers into a maze of doubt where every character hides a secret.

more

Roger Ebert Roger Ebert — 2025-11-06