According to Della-Mattia, Caputo has the right to his personal opinion and social media page.
Comments regarding murdered right-wing activist Charlie Kirk are not considered disrespectful, regardless of agreement.
When municipal council members are elected and sworn into office, they must take a Declaration of Office, which is a solemn promise to act faithfully, avoid conflicts of interest, and remain loyal to the Crown.
The Municipal Act includes specific promises, such as not receiving payment for biased exercise of office and disclosing pecuniary interests.
A councillor’s job is to serve the needs of their constituents – those who elect them to office — impartially and respect the law.
While members of council are held to a higher level of scrutiny, they do not give up their freedom of speech in their oath.
Author's summary: Council members retain freedom of speech.